Bennett's Orlly's logo with stylized text and a shamrock symbol.

Your Lively South La Crosse, WI Tavern

See why locals call it their go-to.

Bennett O'Riley’s is serving up bold bites and pub favorites.

MENU
Drink Menu
Plate of traditional British bangers and mash featuring browned sausages on creamy mashed potatoes, topped with rich onion gravy and served with a side of peas.
Close-up of a taco pizza topped with seasoned ground beef, shredded lettuce, diced tomatoes, shredded cheese, and crushed tortilla chips on a golden-brown crust.

Some nights call for something more than takeout. Whether you're unwinding after work, catching up with friends, or just chasing something made from scratch. Bennett O'Riley's South La Crosse, WI, location is exactly where you want to be. This neighborhood pub isn't just a place to eat. It's a place to belong.

Hearty Pub Fare That Hits the Spot

This South Side pub keeps things simple in the best way: generous plates, bold flavors, and plenty to pass around. Think stacked burgers, crispy starters, and creative pizzas that actually fill you up, so you leave with a happy stomach and an even better mood. Pair it with an ice-cold beer or a smooth cocktail, and suddenly an ordinary night turns into one you'll talk about later.

People enjoying food and drinks at a tavern.

Game Nights, Gatherings, and Wedding Catering

From after-work drinks to game-day crowds, this is where people meet to relax, laugh, and stay a while. Hosting something bigger? The South Side crew can help with parties, office get-togethers, and even wedding catering, so your guests get the same crowd-pleasing flavors and easygoing vibe you love at the restaurant.

Whether you're starting a night out or wrapping up the week, there's always a seat waiting for you in this tavern. Swing in for dinner, linger over a few drinks, and see why people keep coming back. Ready for a relaxed night with good food and strong drinks? Visit Bennett O'Riley's South today, or contact us in advance to plan your next get-together.

Don’t Just Take Our Word for It.

What do you think?

Leave a Review

  • Literally delicious. I'm a Friday Fish fry and Old Fashion girl and after my childhood go-too was closed I struggled to find that same level of greatness. Corey at Bennett's south solidified that. Experience was great, bathrooms clean, atmosphere 100% and food is superb!

    Stephanie F.

  • I would’ve taken pictures but it was too delicious and we ate everything too quickly. Corey and Lidia were great, kept checking in on us and bringing our stuff out quick. We had the fish fry, fish dinner, and brisket sandwich. All of it was great. Everybody enjoyed. I especially recommend the fries with the Jameson aioli, it was so good. I’m thinking this will be our new regular place!

    Abigail S.

  • I love going to Bennett's on the South side because the food is delicious and reasonable all made from scratch, the drinks are reasonably priced. Most of all the staff is phenomenal! Pat is super friendly always on top of things, Lydia is sweet and works hard. Sheena is always smiling and Corey is friendly. They are all fantastic and it makes a terrific hang when u consider all that's mentioned above! I love the place it's definitely a 5 out of 5. I would and do recommend it to everyone!

    Kristi S.

  • Had a fantastic experience! The service was top-notch—Sheena was attentive, friendly, and made sure everything was perfect. The food was outstanding and arrived fast and hot. The wings are absolutely the bomb, the fries are crispy and delicious, and the Reuben egg rolls are a must-try. Highly recommend! Will definitely be back.

    Alee T.

  • Had a date here with my gf, and had a pretty great time! They got my margarita wrong, but they noticed before I did, and brought me another drink for free. I didn't even mind! Fantastic service! Great staff, decent food, underrated location. Will visit again!

    Ryott A.

  • I was really pleased with the food, would highly recommend. Our server was very attentive and I thank the staff for that. The Saturday we visited they had a musician playing which was awesome. Keep up the great work!

    Chris W.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Yes, and that's the whole point. You’ll find hearty pub fare, specialty pizzas, shareable appetizers, and classic comfort dishes made fresh and served hot. That means better flavor, fresher ingredients, and food that actually tastes like someone cared.

  • Absolutely. Whether it's a backyard bash or a full wedding catering service, the team brings the same high-quality food and friendly service to your event. Reach out through the catering inquiry page to get started.

  • It's built for it. The vibe is relaxed, the space is welcoming, and the staff is the kind that actually checks in on you. Bring your crew, there's room, good food, and great drinks waiting.